Yeah the rotor was covered in rust dust when I took the tire off im sure it's never been changed. I love by lefty loosy right tightly, but everyone keeps telling me I'm going the wrong way so before I try again I wanted to be sure. Also I have been spraying penetration oil on it almost every day for a week. Got me a 3/4 in drive breaker bar and an actual hub nut socket 32mm and that puppy ain't breaking for nothing ? thanks for your advice